By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Herald Today
  • More
Reading: Should churches allow sex offenders to hold leadership roles?
Share
Notification
Donate
  • Local Church News
    Local Church NewsShow More
    Vatican Secretary of State Cardinal Pietro Parolin talks to EWTN Vatican correspondent Colm Flynn on March 19, 2022.
    Cardinal Parolin Says Nigeria’s Conflict Is ‘Social,’ Not Religious, Prompting Pushback| National Catholic Register
    13 hours ago
    Some black lives do not matter: Black Christians slaughtered in Nigeria, no one cares
    Some black lives do not matter: Black Christians slaughtered in Nigeria, no one cares
    20 hours ago
    Living-Waters-Unlimited-Church
    ‘Church’s silence fuelling national corruption, insecurity’
    1 day ago
    Living-Waters-Unlimited-Church
    Cleric laments spiritual weakness of Nigerian Church, calls for repentance
    1 day ago
    'Christian genocide' or a crisis of narratives? – DW – 10/20/2025
    ‘Christian genocide’ or a crisis of narratives? – DW – 10/20/2025
    1 day ago
  • World Christian News
    World Christian NewsShow More
    Spike in anti-Christian hate crimes in Europe are underreported
    Spike in anti-Christian hate crimes in Europe are underreported
    1 hour ago
    Americans with a positive view of religion are on the rise: Pew
    Americans with a positive view of religion are on the rise: Pew
    1 hour ago
    Bolivian president-elect thanks God after election victory
    Bolivian president-elect thanks God after election victory
    2 hours ago
    Why we cannot 'agree to disagree' with the Left
    Why we cannot ‘agree to disagree’ with the Left
    2 hours ago
    A growing church reality: Digital worship fatigue
    A growing church reality: Digital worship fatigue
    2 hours ago
  • Business
    BusinessShow More
  • Health
    HealthShow More
    CHOCOLATE CHIP BANANA BREAD with cottage cheese (healthy recipe!)
    5 days ago
    ONE-PAN BAKED CHICKEN and POTATOES | Healthy + Easy Meal Prep Recipe
    2 weeks ago
    SAY NO! TO HEBREW WOMEN DELIVERY!
    3 weeks ago
    The Tiny Mindset Shift That Changed My Health (& Weight!)
    3 weeks ago
    COTTAGE CHEESE FRITTATA with Veggies (Healthy Breakfast Idea!)
    3 weeks ago
  • Technology
    TechnologyShow More
    Image for the large product module
    The best noise-canceling headphones for 2025
    20 minutes ago
    Fujifilm's X-T30 III is its latest camera with a film simulation dial
    Fujifilm’s X-T30 III adds a film simulation dial and 6K video
    2 hours ago
    Image for the large product module
    The best wireless earbuds for 2025
    2 hours ago
    Nigeria, Denmark sign MoU to foster innovation
    Nigeria, Denmark sign MoU to foster innovation
    3 hours ago
    PTI Calls for Inauguration of Africa Energy Bank
    PTI Calls for Inauguration of Africa Energy Bank
    4 hours ago
  • Features
    • Church Events
    • Gospel Music
    • Impact Word
    • Sermons
    FeaturesShow More
    Rev. Tony Ogugu: Exemplifying Leadership Through Service and Impact
    1 week ago
    Prophesy Is Fulfilling
    7 months ago
    PFN DELTA STATE INAUGURATES NEW EXECUTIVES
    1 year ago
    Religious Shift in Iran: Mass Mosque Closures as Iranians Turn to Christianity
    1 year ago
    PFN SECRETARIAT BUILDING COMPLETED AFTER 30 YEARS – HERALDTODAY
    1 year ago
Reading: Should churches allow sex offenders to hold leadership roles?
Share
Herald TodayHerald Today
Font ResizerAa
Search
  • Business
  • Features
    • Church Events
    • Gospel Music
    • Impact Word
    • Sermons
  • Health
  • Local Church News
  • Technology
  • World Christian News
  • Quick Access
    • About
    • Privacy Policy
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • Business
  • Features
  • Health
  • Local Church News
  • Technology
  • World Christian News
  • Quick Access
© 2024 | Herald Today
Herald Today > Blog > World Christian News > Should churches allow sex offenders to hold leadership roles?
World Christian News

Should churches allow sex offenders to hold leadership roles?

heraldtoday
Last updated: 2025/01/15 at 3:11 PM
heraldtoday 9 months ago
Share
Should churches allow sex offenders to hold leadership roles?
SHARE


By Sarah McDugal, Op-ed contributor Wednesday, January 15, 2025
Chuck Adair, a volunteer with Watermark Community Church in Texas, is also a registered sex offender.
Chuck Adair, a volunteer with Watermark Community Church in Texas, is also a registered sex offender. | YouTube/Cross Community Church – Poteau Campus

More and more frequently, reports surfaced about church leaders who have a history of sexually predatory behavior. Last week, headlines revealed that yet another church had placed a lifetime-registered child sex offender in a pastoral role, this time in Texas. News like this once seemed shocking. In today’s social climate, however, it feels almost routine.

Communities of faith are left to sort out the answers to pressing questions, starting with: Should churches allow individuals with such histories to assume leadership roles, even as volunteers?

Some argue that denying ministry roles due to past behavior equals a denial of the power of the Gospel to change sinners. Others insist that any deviation should result in a permanent ban from ministry of any kind. Where do we draw the line? How do we untangle the confusion?

Get Our Latest News for FREE

Subscribe to get daily/weekly email with the top stories (plus special offers!) from The Christian Post. Be the first to know.

One thing is certain — we cannot continue leaving this question unaddressed.

As you (and perhaps your church leadership team) navigate these issues on behalf of your own community, here are five aspects to carefully consider:

1. Platforming encourages trust in the untrustworthy

Churches, as sacred spaces, carry significant influence in shaping trust among congregants. Let’s say a church decides to reinstate a leader who has a history of harming the vulnerable, but they decide to set strict guardrails around the leader’s access to children (or women, depending on the history). Even if offenders are barred from direct contact with minors, their placement in leadership roles sends an implicit message of endorsement.

A person serving in any leadership capacity is automatically perceived as vetted and approved, making it far easier for them to manipulate unsuspecting individuals. Holding a platform of any type serves to disarm potential victims who might otherwise remain cautious. Why? Because people tend to naturally assume that a church would never endorse someone unworthy of trust.

Predators thrive in environments that grant credibility. Regardless of policies intended to mitigate contact with vulnerable individuals, churches that elevate those with known histories to positions of influence risk facilitating future harm.

ASK: Can our church community guarantee that returning this person to a ministry role will not result in undeserved trust and access to the vulnerable?

2. Leadership encourages entitlement

Leadership positions inherently grant influence and visibility — ingredients which stoke entitlement for those who crave power over others. When individuals have committed grave harm, returning to the spotlight sets the stage to reignite the patterns that led to their original offenses. A leadership platform naturally fosters ego and entitlement, reinforcing harmful tendencies rather than encouraging genuine humility and accountability. This is compounded when the leader’s history is kept quiet or downplayed.

When churches allow offenders to assume leadership roles, they inadvertently suggest that past sins carry no lasting consequences for behavior within the faith community. This mindset perpetuates the very first lie in Eden, when the serpent whispered in Genesis 3:4 that disobedience to God did not actually bring death. Exploitation and predation do indeed cause death — they murder the trust, safety, and innocence of the victim.

True rehabilitation must involve accountability and a steadfast denial of the privileges and prestige that easily enable further harm.

ASK: Can we conscientiously trust that a return to leadership in this case will not be fuel for further entitlement and ego that ultimately results in disgrace to God’s work?

3. The Church’s standards must surpass secular society

In secular professions such as medicine, a physician known to sexually assault patients would be stripped of their credentials. Why, then, should a pastor — a role requiring even greater moral accountability — be treated differently? The biblical call to live above reproach demands a higher standard than the secular world, not a lower one.

The Church, as a moral beacon, undermines its witness when it excuses behaviors that even secular society condemns. If Christians truly believe that life is sacred, that sex is sacred, and that Paul meant what he said in 1 Corinthians 5:11 and 6:18-20. If we are not to associate with those who claim to be a believer “yet indulges in sexual sin, … or is abusive. … don’t even eat with such people”, then can we biblically justify placing such an individual back into leadership? The church’s higher moral standard should not only guide decision-making but also reflect the gravity of spiritual leadership responsibilities.

When churches enable offenders to return to leadership, they fail to embody the accountability that is clearly commanded by scripture and even modeled in secular society.

ASK: Would secular society remove credentials from this person for what they have done? If so, how can we do less and still call ourselves a morally sound organization?

4. Predators cannot be trusted in leadership roles

Sexual predators are skilled deceivers, often leveraging trust and influence to manipulate the trust and vulnerability of those around them. Once a leader has demonstrated a willingness to abuse power and exploit trust, they have proven themselves unfit for leadership and disqualified themselves. By placing them back into positions of authority, churches showcase a dangerous naivete about the nature of predatory behavior patterns.

Abuse survivors are frequently dismissed with platitudes about forgiveness and grace, while abusers are handed the microphone and given standing ovations. This dynamic not only compounds the harm done but also perpetuates the ignorance and gullibility that predators rely upon.

A leader who has abused power granted to them in the past, or who has exploited the trust and privileges placed in them as a result of their position, is unlikely to change without comprehensive accountability structures — and even then, it is wisest for public leadership to remain off the table.

ASK: Does this course of action prioritize safety for those who have experienced harm, or are we focused on rehabilitating public image and protecting the position of a human we idolize?

5. Removal from leadership is not a denial of redemption

Finally, denying offenders leadership roles does not equate to denying their access to forgiveness or redemption. Earthly accountability does not limit the reach of the gospel, nor does it hedge the transforming power of conversion. Redemption is a matter between the individual and God. Churches can support the spiritual growth of offenders without granting access to ministry platforms that risk endangering others.

By permanently barring predatory offenders from leadership roles, churches affirm that both forgiveness and accountability can coexist. Leadership, however, is not a right — it is a sacred trust. No human possesses an innate entitlement to any role of authority or influence. These roles must be earned through lasting trustworthy behavior, and they should be revoked when patterns of action destroy trust. This distinction ensures that safety and justice are prioritized without precluding opportunities for personal repentance and restoration in other areas.

ASK: How can we support the journey of repentance in this situation, without compromising the safety of the lambs or collaborating in a dynamic where we endanger this leader’s ability to recover by putting power back in their hands?

The theology of accountability

Scripture repeatedly underscores the importance of accountability for leaders. James 3:1 warns that teachers will be judged more strictly, and 1 Timothy 3:2 states that overseers must be “above reproach.” Leadership in the church is not a privilege but a weighty responsibility that demands the utmost integrity.

Can any church place someone with a history of sexual offenses in leadership without contradicting these biblical principles? Even if a person appears to show remorse, how can a community truly know that it is not merely the manipulative tactics of a skilled deceiver at work? What steps can be taken to avoid conveying the message that the church prioritizes grace for offenders over justice for victims — a dangerous and unscriptural imbalance?

The Church’s role in protecting the vulnerable

Jesus was clear about the gravity of exploiting the innocent, saying, “If anyone causes one of these little ones … to stumble, it would be better for them to have a large millstone hung around their neck” (Matthew 18:6).

Should the church not also embody this protective stance, creating an environment where the vulnerable are safe and supported?

Allowing sex offenders into leadership positions risks retraumatizing survivors, creates wide-open opportunities for recidivism, and undermines the trust of congregants. If we wish to align with scripture, then leadership should only be entrusted to those whose lives align with the high moral standards expected of shepherds.

This stance is not about withholding grace or forbidding second chances; it is about safeguarding the sacred trust placed in spiritual leaders. It is about honoring the survivors who look to the church for safety and upholding the integrity of the Gospel message.

If the community of faith wishes to follow the mandate of Scripture, then churches must prioritize the protection of the vulnerable, set higher standards for leadership than secular institutions, and ensure that forgiveness is not conflated with exemption from accountability. By doing so, we not only protect our congregations but also preserve our witness as communities faithfully rooted in doing justice, loving mercy, and walking humbly (Micah 6:8).

Sarah McDugal is an author, speaker, abuse recovery coach, and co-founder of Wilderness to WILD & the TraumaMAMAs mobile app. She creates courses, community, and coaching for women recovering from deceptive sexual trauma, coercive control, and intimate terrorism. 



Source link

Related

You Might Also Like

Spike in anti-Christian hate crimes in Europe are underreported

Americans with a positive view of religion are on the rise: Pew

Bolivian president-elect thanks God after election victory

Why we cannot ‘agree to disagree’ with the Left

A growing church reality: Digital worship fatigue

heraldtoday January 15, 2025 January 15, 2025
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Previous Article School Of Money -SBLS 1
Next Article Andrew Tate, Benny Johnson and the crisis of biblical masculinity Andrew Tate, Benny Johnson and the crisis of biblical masculinity
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow US

Find US on Social Medias
Facebook Twitter Youtube Instagram

Weekly Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

Popular News
G3 Ministries announces Scott Aniol as new president
World Christian News

G3 Ministries announces Scott Aniol as new president

heraldtoday By heraldtoday 3 months ago
GROWING UNTO MATURITY || APOSTLE MICHAEL OROKPO
Get set for tonight’s prophetic and testimony night at our commanding the day midnight prayers.
A brighter future for Nigeria — Technology — The Guardian Nigeria News – Nigeria and World News
Call for Applications for Women Founders
- Advertisement -
Ad imageAd image

Confirmed

0

Death

0

More Information:Covid-19 Statistics
Home
Herald Today

“Get yourself up on a high mountain, O Zion, bearer of good news, Lift up your voice mightily, O Jerusalem, bearer of good news; Lift it up, do not fear. Say to the cities of Judah, Here is your God!” Isaiah 40:9. 

  • Categories:
  • Sermons
  • World Christian News
  • Technology
  • Uncategorized
  • Local Church News
  • Health
  • Gospel Music
  • Impact Word
  • Church Events
  • weapons of our warfare

Quick Links

  • About
  • Become A Smartphone Manufacturer
  • Blog
  • Business Home 5
  • Contact
  • Customize Interests
  • Disclaimer
  • Home Business
  • My Bookmarks
  • Privacy Policy
  • SHARE YOUR STORY TO THE WORLD FOR FREE

About US

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer

© 2024 | Herald Today

Herald TodayHerald Today
Follow US
© 2024 | Herald Today
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?